Menupickcom lists publicly available information. We are not affiliated with the restaurants shown. How we source and check listings

Menupickcom

The Prospect Tavern menu

8 dishes across 5 sections Moderately expensive American restaurant

Prices transcribed from the printed menu, last checked

Menu The Prospect Tavern photo menu 1
Photographed in store, August 2026. See all 4 pages

Photos of the printed menu

Photographed in store in August 2026. The dish list below covers everything we could read clearly; the full card has more.

Salads 8 dishes

  • Mediterranean Salad US$16.50

    Romaine, roasted pepper, onions, feta, cranberries, kalamata olives, croutons, honey red wine vinaigrette

  • Cobb Salad US$18.70

  • Santé Fe Salad US$16.50

    Mixed green, Monterey Jack, Cheddar cheese, pico de gallo, corn, avocado, tortilla bowl, lemon herb dressing

  • Buffalo Salad US$16.50

    Romaine, avocado, croutons, cucumber, tomato, red onion, blue cheese dressing

  • Brie And Strawberry Salad US$16.50

    Baby spinach, strawberries, dried cranberries, sunflower seeds, candied walnuts, brie, raspberry vinaigrette

  • Arugula And Pear Salad US$15.40

    Sliced pear, shaved Parmesan, lemon, olive oil

  • Chopped Kale Caesar Salad US$15.40

    Kale, Parmesan, croutons, Caesar dressing

  • Asian Salad US$15.40

    Mixed green, noodle crisps, green peas, chick peas, sesame seeds, orange ginger dressing

Pizza 7 dishes

  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza US$18.70

    Breaded chicken, blue cheese dressing

  • #2 Pizza US$18.70

    Sausage, portobello, onion

  • Sliced Eggplant Pizza US$17.60

    Baked eggplant, mozzarella, marinara

  • Hot Honey Pizza US$18.70

    Ricotta, Pepperoni, Hot Honey

  • #1 Pizza US$18.70

    Pepperoni, jalapeño, onions

  • Cheese Pizza US$15.40

    Cheese and tomato sauce

  • Margherita Pizza US$16.50

    Garlic, basil, fresh mozzarella, marinara

Appetizers 13 dishes

  • Coconut Shrimp US$17.60

    Horseradish orange marmalade

  • Prime Poppers US$17.60

    Shredded prime rib, onion, peppers, Cheddar cheese, hulled jalapeño shell

  • Potato Skins US$14.30

    Bacon, Cheddar cheese, scallions, sour cream side

  • Bavarian Pretzel US$14.30

    Spicy honey mustard

  • Spinach And Artichoke Cheese Dip US$15.40

    Tortilla chips, garlic toast

  • Pork Dumplings US$15.40

    Fried or steamed, ginger soy sauce

  • Fried Calamari US$17.60

    Marinara sauce

  • Mussels Or Clams US$17.60

    White or red sauce, garlic toast

  • Macaroni And Cheese Balls US$15.40

    Pink sauce, Parmesan cheese

  • Seared Sea Scallops US$18.70

    Chorizo, kale, cannellini beans, lemon balsamic sauce

  • Chicken Wings, Bites Or Tenders US$16.50

    Choice of one sauce: buffalo, BBQ, honey sriracha, Asian sesame, orange garlic

  • Jalapeño Cheddar Hummus US$15.40

    Toasted pita, celery, carrots

  • Chicken Tacos US$15.40

    Shredded lettuce, Monterey Jack, Cheddar, bean spread, pico de gallo, jalapeño avocado, soft tortilla

Entrees 10 dishes

  • Corned Beef Brisket US$24.20

    Corned beef, steamed cabbage, carrots, baked potato

  • Seafood Linguini Scampi US$35.20

    White wine, lemon and garlic scampi sauce, (please ask your server for today's fresh seafood collection)

  • Strip Steak And Cheddar Grits US$31.90

    NY strip steak, asparagus, crispy onions

  • Crab Stuffed Salmon US$28.60

    Asparagus, lemon, couscous, lobster sauce

  • Chef's Pasta US$24.20

    Sauteed sausage, portobello, baby kale, creamy brown Parmesan sauce

  • Crispy Chicken Cognac US$27.50

    Ham, cheese, sautéed spinach, mashed potatoes

  • Lemon Herb Chicken US$25.30

    Herb encrusted chicken, lemon butter sauce, mashed potatoes, sauteed vegetables

  • Pot Roast US$26.40

    Angus beef tenderloin, brown gravy sauce, carrots, sauteed vegetables, mashed potatoes

  • Cod And Chips US$26.40

    Lightly beer-battered cod, french fries, malt vinegar, tartar sauce

  • Eggplant Parm US$24.20

Sides 8 dishes

  • Cole Slaw US$4.40

  • House Salad US$6.60

  • Sweet Potato Fries US$6.60

  • Onion Rings US$6.60

  • French Fries US$6.60

  • Mozzarella Sticks US$6.60

  • Baked Potato US$6.60

  • Vegetables US$6.60

Soup 3 dishes

  • French Onion US$11.00

  • Texas Beef Chili US$13.20

  • Chicken Couscous US$9.90

Sandwiches 11 dishes

  • Buffalo Chicken Wrap US$18.70

    Grilled or breaded chicken, cucumber, avocado, tomato, jalapeño, lettuce, blue cheese dressing

  • Turkey And Brie Wrap US$17.60

    Sliced turkey, brie cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, baby spinach, honey dijon mustard

  • Salmon Sandwich US$19.80

    Grilled salmon, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, tartar sauce

  • Sliced Prime Rib US$24.20

  • Open-Faced Reuben US$17.60

    Corned beef or pastrami, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, Russian dressing, rye bread

  • Pulled Pork US$17.60

    BBQ sauce, coleslaw, brioche bun

  • Cajun Chicken US$18.70

    Grilled chicken, Pepper Jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, avocado jalapeño spread, brioche bun

  • Cuban US$18.70

    Roasted pork, sliced ham, pickles, Swiss cheese, spicy brown mustard, pressed inside-out roll

  • Shrimp Tacos (2) US$19.80

    Grilled shrimp, flour tortilla, green salsa

  • Portobello US$15.40

    Portobello mushroom, zucchini, roasted peppers, eggplant, provolone cheese, brioche bun

  • Lobster Roll US$27.50

    Lobster salad, tarragon, mayonnaise, celery, scallions, toasted roll

Burgers 10 dishes

  • CheeseBurger US$16.50

  • Sirloin US$17.60

    Caramelized onions, Swiss cheese, au jus, brioche bun

  • Trashed BBQ Burger US$17.60

    Angus beef, Cheddar cheese, barbeque sauce, smoked bacon, crispy onion

  • California US$17.60

    Angus beef, bacon, avocado, American cheese, brioche bun

  • Black And Blue US$17.60

    Angus beef, Cajun rub, blue cheese, crispy onions, brioche bun

  • Cheeseburger Sliders US$15.40

    Choice of cheese

  • Hamburger US$15.40

  • Ranchero US$17.60

    Angus beef, Pepper Jack cheese, jalapeño, green salsa, avocado

  • Turkey Burger US$17.60

    Ground turkey, avocado, Swiss cheese, brioche bun

  • Brie And Spinach US$17.60

    Angus beef, sautéed spinach, brie cheese, sourdough toast

About these prices

Restaurants change prices without notice, and a menu photographed in August may already be out of date. Treat these figures as a guide, not a quote. If you spot a difference, tell us and we will re-check it.

Other menus in Madison

Prices transcribed the same way, each with the date last checked.

All Madison listings
Call Menu Directions